Weather

Vitebsk
Brest
Hrodna
Homiel
Mahilyow
Мinsk

Statistics

Articles View Hits
26998284

Recommend Print

Psychiatrist Postnov paid for criticism

We remind readers about the fate of whistleblowers from medicine. Igor Postnov graduated from medical school with honors, worked as a district pediatrician. Until 2008, his employment records only write thank-you for the good work. But as soon as Igor Postnov spoke aloud about diseases Vitebsk health became an outcast in the Ministry of Health.

The doctor twice deprived of work, but it recovered – albeit in other positions, he settled for less pay. He was forced to undergo a psychiatric examination. But he still continued to cut the plain truth about the situation in hospitals Vitebsk and unenviable position of doctors.

In an interview with the regional and national media reporters asked Igor Postnov reasonable question, they say, why would he need to be a "black sheep"? To which Igor Postnov answered as follows:

– In September 2012 I posted on the Internet all the facts: what was promised to fulfill Chairman of the Vitebsk Oblast Executive Committee Alexander Kosinets, and what really made? And in December, announced that they do not extend the contract with me.

By the way, lean is always mentioned in his interview that suffered for personal beliefs.

– I cannot stand seeing that the conditions under which sometimes turn out to be our patients, especially children,– he explained his "dissident".

– It all began in 2008 when the Vitebsk Oblast Executive Committee headed by Alexander Kosinets. In medical circles, the appointment of Doctor of Medicine was widely seen positively, saying that a colleague is aware of the situation in medicine and everything inside, will be keen to eradicate deficiencies in the health system. However, the governor of Vitebsk led policy of creating cultural capital of Vitebsk. Is a good thing – do not argue. But I have this caused some confusion: how to create a cultural capital, when the social sphere in the region lies on the blades. At the time, only in the health scream screaming many problems. Infectious Diseases Hospital of Vitebsk was similar to a doss-house: living conditions not stand up to scrutiny. 2nd city hospital residents of Vitebsk called "valley of death". There is planned to create a department for the rehabilitation of stroke patients, but the conditions for this have not been established: the old hospital building, built for the factory organizations, chambers resembled dungeons, uncomfortable beds, mattresses with holes in them. Their bed patients simply rot. At the same time equips the Victory Square – a monumental showing off huge amounts of money squandered. By the way, in the republican newspaper "Narodnaya Volya" this ostentation wrote correspondent Sergei Butkevitch (now deceased).

I would like to say about all this personally to Kosinets. But at the reception it has not got to his office would not let me, said that he had no time, offered to enroll in the queue. Only three years later (in 2011), he took me – and when I called to "hot line" that the governor held in early January 2011, and in the presence of journalists asked, they say that you, Alexander Nikolayevich, enough charisma to meet with me one-on-one? And I took Kosinets.

Talked provocatively, I thought, trying to drive me crazy. When I introduced myself, "Dr. Postnov," he said, "What you're a doctor? This I'm a doctor!" Apparently implying that he is a doctor of medical sciences. I retorted: "No, I'm a doctor. And you, Alexander, betrayed medicine, steel, sorry, the regional assistant warden. In general, the doctor, the physician – these words are synonyms. In general, constructive conversation did not happen.

Why this was the reaction on his part – I know.

When Alexander Kosinets back in 2008 did not receive me, I began to write his name on the letter, which pointed out the flaws in the health facilities in Vitebsk. My email is then sent to Provincial Department of Health, there came unsubscribe: that repair is going on it is allocated so much money, etc. That is said that medical institutions is redecorating, but I'm writing something that the medical field requires major repairs.

The First Circle

– Then I went to see the assistant president of Vitebsk region, Viktor Pylypets and openly declared: "Mr. Assistant, you and the President have been deceived. Carry only ostentatious objects." My visit to Pylypets was after a visit to Alexander Lukashenko biofactory in the village should Vitebsk region. There were other visits: Lukashenko hospital opened in Vitebsk, Department of Surgery at the Hospital emergency room. And why would the president not to show the infectious diseases hospital? That's what I asked Pylypets. In addition, all the objects that the new head of the region showing the president, were laid or renovated more to the Chairman of Executive Committee Vladimir Andreychenko.

The visit ended with Pylypets went to secondary school number 4, where I worked as a medical doctor, and confirmed my words: the toilets are broken, in the sports hall of disadvantages. And so on. Almost all of the money that had been scheduled for repair of secondary schools in Vitebsk, transferred our school. And the director even then I got a scolding.

But I do not why went! Not for this, excuse me, bigoted reaction. If we take up the social sphere, it is necessary to solve all drastically.

Strangely, however, an educated man who knew in advance that the love of truth is nothing but trouble, he will not, yet continued to pester power structures. Also argued that all these meetings with citizens are a fiction.

– Four years in Vitebsk based surgical unit number 2 Regional Oncology Center. People are after operations in the corridors. I am responsible for my words, unfortunately, he was faced with this, there has recently lost my mother. Statistics on cancer rates awesome – every 40th resident of Vitebsk is on account of cancer. Surgical unit as claimed Kosinets had to pass in 2011. Do not pass. In September 2012, I posted on the Internet, all these facts to the health facilities of the city: Kosinets is promised and what is really done.

But apparently, the criticism we do not like. In December I announced that to me do not extend the contract.

The second round

– With confidence I think that for criticizing me fired. Other levers of influence on me were not. I'm telling the truth. I'm not any opposition, I voted for this government, sincerely believed her and felt that if the government conducts meetings with citizens, that really wants to know about the true situation in the region, even though it my duty tell what the problems are in the Vitebsk health. It seemed to me that the authorities are interested to build a state in which all would live well – and ordinary doctor, and official. If I had someone slandered or lied to, I think I would be attracted to administrative or criminal liability. But no one in the court with the claim on Postnov off. I decided to act against another. With me just not to renew the contract. Twice, the first time in 2010.

I worked pediatrician at half rate in the children's clinic number three. He worked on the conscience, to 2008 in my workbook only gratitude. But as soon as I started talking about diseases Vitebsk health, I tried to arrange a survey: Am I normal. In 2010 I received a letter from the Vitebsk regional neuropsychiatric clinic with an invitation to come to them in connection with "your repeated calls to various government agencies."

Of course, I did not go anywhere. After 20 days received a second letter from the clinic, where it was said that I was invited to go "in connection with the received attitude of the Vitebsk Oblast Executive Committee." Me and this invitation ignored. Since coming to the end of the term of the prisoner with me labor contract, the administration of city hospital number 3 just was not extended without explanation: human rights in Belarus is no one to help, the more "pocket unions".

I went to the reception to the Assistant to the President of the Vitebsk region. At that time it was already Nikolai Domashkevich. And he ordered me to reinstate.

Restored. But not as a pediatrician. Offered a position from which, they thought, I refuse – a pediatric consultant obstetric units Vitebsk region. I went to the sick children in the village of hitch-hiked over 1.8 million salary. 1.8 million – is at stake and a quarter.

But this post is not given to me to work. Contract signed for two years. Period has expired, the contract was not renewed.

In the fall of 2012 Kosinets all over the country, said a good living in the Vitebsk region, the average salary in the region for 500 dollars, and in 2013 will be 700, I laid out in my online payslip.

Well, I was paid 1.8 million. Do you think that other doctors are much better? My classmate earns in terms of $450, but it is 2 plots in the clinic, and on weekends moonlighting orderly in the hospital.

Beggars doctors – it is a matter of national security. Because for such a salary, they will not work as possible will be arranged by the company, to leave the country. For example, a therapist from the village clinic Zamostochie resigned, went to Russia, wrote to me that he once gave salary 40,000 Russian rubles. This is $1,300.

I was unemployed for a long time – I have stood up for the parents of my patients Zamostochie, Yanovichi and other villages. Began to write letters to the Damashkevich asking me to return to the area. Again, assistant to the president intervened in my fate: he ordered employ Postnov to work according to specialty. They jumped at it, raised my documents, found that in 1992, I held an internship in psychiatry (in pediatrics I passed specialization in 1996). I was offered a psychiatrist at the orphanage.

But it was preceded by a very ugly story.

I was invited by the chief doctor of the district children's hospitals and in the presence of the Chief of Staff and the lawyer said, will pass a psychiatric examination that you can engage in medical practice – I extend my contract with you. I believe he volunteered for this examination. I wanted to work with a pediatrician, besides my mother called me from the villages, begging to go back: Well, there is no one to treat their children as mothers go to Vitebsk expensive.

In the mental hospital I passed the test, then he created medical advisory board. The conclusion of the WCC in good health, but has a particular character.

But officials cannot be trusted. In the children's clinic did not take me back. Even though they knew that I am very good at my job. Do you think they did not check? Checking and cross-checking arranged, cards of patients tested. If something in my work were not so, would arrange re-certification – and all would not need this noise with up survey to arrange.

Perhaps because of the experiences of my mother happened oncology. She was very nervous, especially when the police began to come to the neighbors to wonder what kind of person I am, how I behave. But she knew that I was not doing it for themselves.

Then I was accepted – the post – rehabilitation specialist psychiatrist at the Regional Health Center. The plot is very interesting work, great job. In the salary won, was 3 million, not 1.8. Attended training courses in Minsk.

And here are the vicissitudes of fate courses in Minsk were on the topic of personality psychology, behavioral responses of the individual...

I am sure that I wanted to do a psychopath, find insane, put a serious diagnosis. But my fellow psychiatrists acted honestly, and I thank them for that. Although, unfortunately, in our society, psychiatry is sometimes used as a knife, using the fight against undesirable. And it should not be. Because it's even worse than a prison. In captivity, a person can fight for their rights, and when a man declared insane, he is deprived of every right, he cannot stand up for himself. And imagine if the man mistakenly declared insane?

Psychiatric patients have so far treated compulsorily.

I am a doctor with 20 years of experience. Graduated with honors from medical school, I have over 45 years of his life there was no administrative violations, conflicts with the law, but I had to prove I was mentally healthy. Although I end up myself yet rehabilitated.

I am a contact person, not aggressive, worked perfectly, had no complaints from patients, even adapted to our society. And the fact that I pointed out the problems in health care... So they are! Even the corrupt nature. Imagine nephew Kosinets – chief doctor of the first Vitebsk city hospital, and my boss Alena Martynova a swing man in psychiatry. Moreover, in the year of frugality, as the country with his hand barely making ends meet, the governor built posh house in Vitebsk on the street Dovator. I posted this information on the Internet. That broke the thunder from lightning on my head.

When me not to renew the contract in 2010, the chief pediatrician of the city said, you dishonor their medical colleagues. But I never said a bad word about our doctors. We really lovely human resource in medicine, treatment standards are good. But the conditions are terrible. It is a crime, when in Vitebsk four years based surgical building Oncology Center. Began to build in 2008, before the crisis, the look, and the building would have been exploited. And today there is still no roof. And so on all the objects that I mentioned back in 2008.

It should be recalled. Doctor who raised the most troubling issues, spiteful critics have tried to tarnish the Internet. Unfortunately, state newspaper "Sovetskaya Belorussia", which appealed to Postnov urgent problem by re-directing questions to on whom petitioner complained.

 It seems that patience was crowded when Igor Postnov has once again delivered on one of the sites on the Internet a video message to Vitebsk residents about involuntary hospitalization homeless and socially unsettled citizens. He said that the decision of the Vitebsk Oblast Executive Committee adopted on the eve of the festival "Slavic Bazaar in Vitebsk", the police were obliged to deliver the said category of citizens at the center for involuntary psychiatric hospitalization.

While fans of pop fun, socially disadvantaged people were in restraints. According to Igor Postnov such imprisonment for "treatment" – is nothing short of incitement to hatred on social grounds, and lawlessness. On the front page stories recorded diagnosis of the disease, "a bum". The reason for hospitalization indicated that "for social reasons". Base, "by order of the executive committee." Unfortunately, such "network" does not just homeless. Just the police could not like someone's appearance.

Then, according to Postnov in a psychiatric hospital were escorted to deliver grain growers noticed finding tipsy. Well, after the events unfolded rapidly. Right from the workplace Igor Alexeyevich Postnov carried to the House of the 2nd enclosed compartment of the same hospital, where he was working, having acquainted with the approved by the prosecutor. Then the court of Vitebsk region verdict of involuntary treatment "prisoner of Psychiatry"...

Vladimir Zhigulov